Skip to main content
  • Solutions for Employers

    Enhance your benefits program with a custom strategy that not only engages your employees and helps retain your talent—but also lightens the load on HR.

    How We Help
    • Strategic Partner
    • Professional Enrollment
    • Benefits Education
    • Total Benefits Solution
    • Benefits and Services
    Who We Serve
    • Education
    • Public Sector
    • Automotive
    • Manufacturing
    • Healthcare
  • Resource Library

    Explore our catalog of blog articles, educational videos, customer stories, and more.

    View All Resources

    Resource Types
    • Blog Articles
    • Videos
    • Customer Stories
    • Tools
    • Help Center
    • All Resources

    An Employer's Guide to a Successful Enrollment

    Download the free how-to guide to get your enrollment strategy on the right path. 

    Download Now
  • Help Center
  • Login
  • Strategy
  • Reimbursement Accounts
  • Supplemental Benefits
  • Customer Stories
  • Compliance
American Fidelity Logo

Disability insurance vs. critical illness insurance: Which is better for you?

May 10, 2022

2 minute read

Category: Supplemental Benefits

Learn more about this blog article

If you're trying to decide between disability insurance and critical illness insurance, you may want to consider getting both. They don't offer the same kind of coverage, so choosing one could leave you unprotected in other areas of your life. Here's what you need to know about the differences between the two types of insurance.

What does disability insurance cover?

Disability insurance is designed to financially help you when you're unable to work due to a covered injury or illness. The benefit provides a percentage of your income for a set period of time, allowing you to focus on getting back on your feet without extra financial stress.

To receive your benefit, you may need to provide proof that you can't work and need to "re-prove" this status upon request from your insurance provider. If you improve to the point that you no longer meet the definition of disabled through your disability insurance policy, your payments will end.

Learn more about disability insurance 

What does critical illness insurance offer?

In contrast to disability insurance, critical illness insurance does not cover injuries. Instead, it provides a lump sum payment if you're diagnosed with any illnesses covered on your policy. The diagnosis of illness is the most important factor here, as opposed to whether it keeps you from working. Once the illness has been diagnosed, and you've received your benefit payment from the policy, you won't generally be asked to prove whether you can or cannot work.

Additionally, critical illness insurance isn't based on your income. The maximum benefit amount you'll receive for your illness is detailed in your policy document. Some conditions will provide a bigger benefit than others, and before you choose a policy, you'll want to see what the benefit amounts and covered illnesses are. For example, while a family history of heart disease doesn’t guarantee you will also get it, it’s worth considering if it’s covered in your policy.

Learn more about critical illness insurance 

So, what's the bottom line?

The bottom line when comparing disability insurance and critical illness insurance is that one isn't a replacement for the other. One option also isn't necessarily better than the other. They provide different types of coverage and having both may give you more protection and additional peace of mind.

This blog is up to date as of May 2022 and has not been updated for changes in the law, administration or current events.

  • Tags:
  • Critical Illness
  • Disability

Share:

Related Supplemental Benefits Articles

Who needs disability insurance?

May 01, 2024

3 minute read

Who needs it? Probably everyone. Discover the importance of disability insurance in protecting your income during unexpected illness or injury.

  • Tags:
  • Disability

What Your Medical Plan Won't Cover

November 09, 2023

3 minute read

An affordable health insurance supplemental plan can help cover the costs left by your regular health insurance, so you don't have to worry about it.

  • Tags:
  • Education
  • Cancer
  • Accident
  • Disability
  • Gap
  • Hospital Indemnity
  • Critical Illness
  • Medical

Chasity’s Story: Focus on Surviving

June 07, 2023

3 minute read

Chasity’s diagnosis was a surprise, but her cancer and disability policies helped her be prepared.

  • Tags:
  • Testimonials
  • Disability
  • Cancer

Our logo
  • Strategic Partner
  • For Education
  • For the Public Sector
  • For Automotive
  • For Manufacturing
  • For Healthcare
  • Professional Enrollment
  • AFenroll®
  • Benefits Education
  • Total Benefits Solution
  • Culture and Engagement
  • Benefits and Services
  • Resource Library
  • Blog
  • Customer Stories
  • Tools
  • Help Center
  • Forms
  • AFmobile® App

Contact Us

Careers

  • About Us
  • Annual Report
  • Community Giving
  • News Center
  • facebook
  • Youtube
  • linked-in

© 2025 American Fidelity Assurance Company

  • Privacy Notices |
  • Report Fraud |
  • Terms of Service |
  • Licensing |
  • Special Notices |
  • Accessibility |
  • Cameron Enterprises

This information is intended to be educational. It is general in nature and should not be considered financial, legal or tax advice. Consult an attorney or a tax professional regarding your specific situation. These products may contain limitations, exclusions and waiting periods. Critical illness insurance is inappropriate for people who are eligible for Medicaid coverage.

ESB-9370-0522