We partner with school districts to minimize carriers and streamline benefits administration. From employee education to our enrollment platform and ongoing compliance support, our solutions were built for the education community.  

"Since 2006, American Fidelity has provided personalized service through annual employee benefit reviews and FSA and HRA administration. Our partner is always a quick call away, and I consider Kaitlin and her team to be part of our unofficial HR department."
Jan Bush, Business Manager, Murphysboro CUSD #186, Illinois

Streamline Services to Manage Costs

American Fidelity delivers a single source for your benefits program. This gives you the advantage of one bill, an online account, and a local account manager to handle in-person benefits education and employee enrollment.

*FSA is Flexible Spending Account, HSA is Health Savings Account, HRA is Health Reimbursement Arrangement

Serving Your Region 

American Fidelity holds a strong reputation within the education community and currently works with 530 districts in the Midwest. This local experience makes us well-suited to help our partners better manage the benefits challenges school districts share.

Are You Giving Employees the Education They Deserve?



Individualized Benefits Education

We meet one-on-one with every employee to educate on all their benefits options, not just those we offer. And, we’ll be there year-round, whether in-person or virtually to answer employee questions. They'll also have access to customized education material for your district like an enrollment site, emails, and videos.

Benefit Review Site 

Enrollment Email Reminders

Custom Enrollment Videos 

"Health insurance is scary. And to have somebody that is professional that understands health insurance and can walk employees through what that looks like, to use it on one plan or another, was really a positive thing for our employees."
Paul Ziegler, JD, St. Louis, MO, EducationPlus Executive Director, Employer

A Simple All-in-One Benefits System

AFenroll® provides a secure, year-round system for enrollments and benefits administration. With the ability to enroll employees in core and voluntary benefits, our platform can eliminate paper and streamline your enrollment. AFenroll is provided at no cost as permitted by law and effectively reduces the burden of enrollment administration.

Employer Dashboard

Plan Options

Benefit Summary

Customized Benefits

All American Fidelity benefits are customized at the employee level. Each employee can design the product portfolio that meets his or her needs, instead of a one-size-fits all approach. With this customization, most employees save money by only getting what they need. 


School Districts Served Today


Education Association Relationships


Years Working in Education

Your Local Partner

For over a decade, Kaitlin Economon has worked alongside school administrators in Missouri, Illinois, Iowa and Wisconsin to uncover benefits issues and human resources challenges. Kaitlin looks at benefits trends and offers local, industry knowledge to school districts.

Ready to learn how we can help your district?